David Hollingworth at Atomic MPC has his E3 review of Dark Millennium Online up:
http://www.atomicmpc.com.au/News/217562,homefront-intrigues-red-faction-attracts-and-dark-millennium-underwhelms.aspx/2
It ranks up as the biggest disappointment of the show, given that all was on show was a trailer, and that our interview with Dave Adams, general manager on the game, pretty much added up to a blanket statement of “We’re not talking about *insert topic here* at this time.”
Their main complaints are it looks ‘awfully cartoony – a lot like World of Warcraft’ and that they didn’t give any information out of Vigil Games founder David Adams about classes or gameplay mechanics. Vigil said repeatedly in other E3 interviews that they were just showing off the art style and that they weren’t ready to show off any game mechanics at this date. Other interviewers were got mixed results about teasing tidbits of information out of Vigil employees.
As far as complaints about the art style, it doesn’t really look any different than the art style used in the Dawn of War games (I think Gamestrailer even used Dawn of War footage in their interview of DMO). Games Workshop has total creative authority over the game, so they were clearly happy enough with the art style to let Vigil release what they did. Other than that, in my opinion, World of Warcraft looks great and if people wanted to play a gritty looking MMORPG then Hellgate London would probably have been more successful.